Go Messy or Go Hungry

Sourdough Dessert Pizza {Low FODMAP}

Apr 23, 2020 | Dessert, Pizza, Recipes, Sourdough

Sourdough Dessert Pizza Recipe | Go Messy or Go Hungry

If you follow me on Instagram, you’ve been seeing a lot more homemade pizzas lately. What with our current shelter-in-place situation, it’s not like I’ve got anything else to do or anywhere else to go (my usual deterrent for making sourdough, since it’s a bit of a time consuming process). But what better way to fill time than tending to sourdough right?!

Sourdough Dessert Pizza Recipe | Go Messy or Go Hungry


Plus, we moved into a new place with a gas oven. Which I LOVE for most things because it heats up in no time at all. But it’s proven a little tricky for cooking my wannabe Neapolitan-style pizzas. The name of the game is to get the oven as hot as possible to mimic the 900° wood-fired ovens in true pizzarias. In our electric oven, that meant heating our baking steel up to 500° for an hour just below the top heating element, and then broiling the pizza until the crust was just beginning to brown on the top and bottom.


Sourdough Dessert Pizza Recipe | Go Messy or Go Hungry

But in our gas oven, the flame is on the bottom, and so the broiler is in a compartment below the oven (that area that’s usually a drawer for baking sheets with an electric oven). Initially I thought it’d be even better (fire!), but it’s been hard to get the baking steel hot enough for some reason, leaving us with pizza that’s v done on top and not so much on bottom.

Sourdough Dessert Pizza Recipe | Go Messy or Go Hungry

So we’re going to have to “suffer” through some experiments while I figure out this new oven situation (read: the only suffering that has occured was waiting for the pizza to be ready to eat ?)



Update: we figured it out! I’ve updated the directions below to include a variation for gas ovens, but basically we heat up the baking steel at 500° inside the oven, and heat up a pizza stone inside the broiler drawer thing. We bake the pizza for 4-5 mins in the oven (on the baking steel) — this gets the bottom nice and spotted. Then we move it to the broiler drawer and cook for another 3-4 mins under the broiler (on the stone, but you could totally use a normal baking sheet here) to get the top nice and done!

Sourdough Dessert Pizza Recipe | Go Messy or Go Hungry

A few weekends ago, I made up our usual dough for makes two pizzas, and Marc had the idea to turn one of them into a dessert pizza. Now, in my mind, “dessert pizza” conjures up images of a crumbly cracker crust topped with fruit slices and that sweet cream cheese frosting stuff — not my fave. But Marc was apparently envisioning the Godfather’s version of dessert pizza — “no, like cinnamon roll topping, but on a pizza” were his instructions — and since I’ve already proven that sourdough cinnamon rolls are fantastically delicious, we decided to go for it!

Sourdough Dessert Pizza Recipe | Go Messy or Go Hungry

This dessert pizza did not disappoint. I mean how could it, with that carmelized-almost-burnty sugar, butter, and cinnamon topping?! I sort of screwed up the when shaping the pizza dough and it accidentally got folder over itself, but I think in the end it turned out for the best to have the dough a little thicker than what I normally do for savory pizzas. I’d even venture to recommend keeping the dough thicker (gotta love those happy accidents)!


Update #2: We made this again and I purposefully kept the dough thicker. You can see in the pictures that it got so nice and bubbly inside. Definitely the way to go here!

Sourdough Dessert Pizza

Yield | 2 10-12 inch pizzas
This recipe makes enough dough for two pizzas. I'd recommend making one savory and one dessert (see my sourdough pizza recipe for savory topping ideas), but if you want to make two dessert pizzas, I'd double the cinnamon topping and maple glaze ingredients.
Recipe based on sourdough pizza from The Perfect Loaf.
Timing: I've included timing recommendations for each step, but feel free to adjust if needed. The timing can be quite flexible — see this post for ideas on where and how to adjust to your needs.
Flour: You'll get the best results with "tipo 00" flour (but you can also use regular all-purpose flour in a pinch). I've been using Central Milling Organic Type 00 Normal flour, which I buy online, but any brand that's marked "tipo 00" should work — I've also the Caputo and Anna Napoletana brands, which I've found at Whole Foods.
Starter: I suggest you create your starter following these directions, and maintain it following these. You want your starter to be at its peak when you use it for this recipe (peak = when you would normally feed it). If your starter is at its peak before you need to use it, you can make an intermediate build that will be ready in a few hours. Just add 50g water at 90°F, 50g flour (25g white and 25g whole wheat), and 50g starter to a separate jar, and it should be ready in about 2-3 hours.



  • 427.5 grams "tipo 00" white flour (see notes)
  • 48 grams whole wheat flour (or all-purpose flour)
  • 318 grams water at room temp
  • 13.5 grams salt
  • 70.5 grams mature sourdough starter (see notes)

Cinnamon Topping

  • 3 tablespoons butter or coconut oil softened
  • 3 tablespoons brown sugar
  • 1 teaspoon cinnamon

Maple Glaze

  • 1 tablespoon butter
  • ¼ cup powdered sugar
  • ½ teaspoon vanilla
  • ½ tablespoon maple syrup
  • ½-1 teaspoon water


Mix dough (30 mins) — 1:00 PM

  • Add the flours, water, salt, and starter to a large bowl. Mix with a spoon until the liquid is incorporated and the dough is too stiff to mix anymore. Dump everything out on the counter and mix with your hands until all the crumbs have been incorporated.
  • Slap & fold the dough on your counter for 5-7 minutes, or stretch and fold the dough until it's strong and resists stretching.

Bulk Fermentation + stretch & fold (2.5 hrs) — 1:30 – 4:00 PM

  • Place dough in a clean bowl, cover with a towel, and place somewhere warm (75-77°F). A water heater closet, sunny window (or even outside depending on the temp), next to a coffee maker that's on, or on top of an oven that's on all work (or you could get an actual proofing container). Every 30 minutes, stretch & fold the dough (each way — top, bottom, left, and right). If the dough is stiff and resists stretching after the third time, let it rest the remaining time. If it's still very stretchy, do a fourth stretch & fold.

Shape & refrigerate (overnight) — 4:00 PM

  • After the 2.5 hours are up, dump the dough onto your counter and shape into a boule. You can sort of spin the dough on the counter, and then pull it slightly toward you to create tension — you want it to get nice & taut.
  • Place the dough in a lightly oiled bowl, cover with plastic wrap, and refrigerate overnight.

Divide & ball (30 mins) — 12:00 PM next day

  • Remove the dough from the refrigerator and dump onto the counter. Divide into two equal pieces (or however many pizzas you're making, if you've scaled the recipe). Shape the dough ball by tucking the dough into itself. Then pinch the bottom and turn the ball in your hands, turning and pinching until it forms a very tight ball. Finally, spin the ball on the counter again and then pull it a few times toward your body to make sure there are no seams. See this video for a better idea.
  • Transfer the dough to a lightly oiled pan or sheet and cover with plastic wrap (I actually use two bowls — something with high walls works best so it doesn't stick to the plastic).

PROOF (6 HRS) — 12:30 – 6:30 PM

  • Place the dough in your warm place to proof for 6 hours. When it's done, the dough should have relaxed from the tight ball shape and should be soft to touch, and you should be able to see some bubbles inside.
  • You can either bake the dough now or place it in the refrigerator for several hours to overnight.

Preheat oven (1 hr) — 5:30 PM

  • An hour before you plan to eat, preheat your oven to 550°F or as hot as it will go. (Preheating for this long ensures that your oven temperature is stable and that your steel or stone have gathered a lot of heat.) If you have an electric oven, place your baking steel or stone (steel is highly recommended!) in the oven a few rungs down from the top. If you have a gas oven with the flame on the bottom and the broiler in a drawer below the oven, place the baking steel in the oven a rung or two above the BOTTOM of the oven. Then, place a second baking stone or other baking surface in the broiler drawer (we use the middle rung).
  • 30 minutes before you bake the pizza, place the entire proofing pan (dough, plastic, and all) into the refrigerator. Having slightly cool dough makes it so much easier to shape.

Prepare toppings

  • Meanwhile, prepare the cinnamon topping and glaze. Soften 3 tablespoons butter in the microwave (don't melt it all the way) in a small bowl. Add in brown sugar and cinnamon and stir to combine. Set aside.
  • For the maple glaze, melt 1 tablespoon butter in the microwave (melt this one all the way this time) in another small bowl. Add powdered sugar and vanilla – it will be thick and sticky. Stir in maple syrup. Add water until desired consistency is reached.
  • If making a savory pizza as well (we usually make one savory and one dessert), prepare any toppings following instructions in my sourdough pizza post.

Shape & Bake (10 mins each) — 6:30 PM

  • Cut two pieces of parchment paper to fit your steel or stone.
  • Remove the dough from the refrigerator. Generously dust the top of one of the dough balls with flour (I use sticky rice flour for this) and gently remove it from its container. Place top-side down on your counter. Lightly flour your hands and the top of the dough.
  • Shape the pizza: Start by creating an indentation around the edge of the dough to form the crust. Try not to press any gas out of the dough here — you want the bubbles to rise up and get that nice char. Now gently lift the dough up and, using your fists, gently stretch the dough as you work around (leaving the crust part alone), letting gravity help you stretch it to your desired size. I recommend a smaller, thicker size for your dessert pizza, so just one or two fist stretches should do the trick. See this video for a better idea on how to shape the dough.
  • Lay the dough on one piece of parchment paper and adjust so that it's a circle. Spread cinnamon topping around the center of the pizza, leaving a crust along the edge.
  • Regardless if you have a gas or electric oven, turn it onto broil (as high as it will go).
  • Bake the pizza: Using a peel if you have it, slide the parchment paper and dough into the oven, on top of your stone or steel. If you have an electric oven, bake for 5-10 minutes, rotating once halfway through. (Definitely use the pizza peel for this, and make sure you don't catch the parchment paper on fire...) If you have a gas oven, bake for 4-5 minutes in the oven (but with the broiler on). Then move the pizza into the broiler drawer for 3-4 more minutes (rotating after about 2 mins).
  • When the pizza is done, remove and transfer to a plate or tray. Allow to mostly cool before drizzling the maple glaze on top (if it's hardened, microwave again for a few seconds). Repeat with the other dough ball, or make a savory pizza.
  • Slice and enjoy!

You might also like

Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Sourdough Bread

Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Sourdough Bread

Maybe pumpkin sourdough bread sounds weird (although by now y’all are used to my sourdough escapades, right?), but I promise you it’s not. Somewhere between the flavor and consistency of a quick bread (think banana bread) and an actual loaf of bread, this recipe yields results that are sweet but not too sweet…

Sourdough Babka

Sourdough Babka

So somehow we’ve developed a joke in our family that I’m Polish. Nothing against anybody who is actually Polish, but I am NOT POLISH — I’m half Irish and half Slovak, which is NOT THE SAME, k? I’m sure you can already see how the joke developed…

Sourdough Pizza {low FODMAP}

Sourdough Pizza {low FODMAP}

PIZZAAAAAAAA! Y’all should know by now that pizza is my love language. I think I’ve posted more pictures of pizza to Instagram than anything else. (Look, even one of my earliest pictures was of pizza.) …

Leave a comment


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This